Home > Insurance Scams > Insurance Payout Scams

Insurance Payout Scams

By: Chris Nickson - Updated: 4 Sep 2012 | comments*Discuss
 
Insurance Critical Illness Cancer

Buying critical illness insurance is supposed to offer peace of mind for the moments when your world falls apart with a terrible medical diagnosis. But it transpires that the peace of mind can be anything but that, as insurance companies reportedly reject a staggering one in five claims.

How It Works

When you apply for insurance, you fill out a questionnaire about your medical history. Once that's completed and you begin making payments, most people assume everything is fine, and they're fully covered.

What they don't realise is that the medical notes of applicants aren't checked until they make a claim against the insurance, as the insurers say it costs too much to thoroughly check every single application. However, when you do claim, they'll go back and look at your doctor's notes. If there's a disparity between them and the answers you gave in the application questionnaire, they can, and very likely will, reject your claim.

Their right, under the law, is that if a customer fails to disclose information sought by the insurer, the provider can end the cover and reject a claim. However, the original questions can be very vague or confusingly worded. Even so, the company has the legal right to reject the claim if they consider the information to be inaccurate, whether deliberate or accidental.

In one recent instance, a cancer claim was rejected by an insurer. The reason given was that she hadn't disclosed the fact that she was diabetic. In fact she'd experienced gestational diabetes, a rise in sugar levels during pregnancy, a condition that affects one in 30 women during pregnancy; in other words, it's more a condition of pregnancy than an illness in itself. In most cases it vanishes after the birth. However, since the word diabetes appeared in her doctor's notes (which were reviewed when she made her claim) and she'd stated she'd never had it, the insurer felt within their legal rights to reject a claim for a different and unconnected condition.

How To Avoid It

About the only way to avoid a rejection is to be utterly honest. Make an appointment with your doctor before you fill out the application and go through the questions thoroughly. He will have your notes in front of him and can check for any mention of conditions.

If that isn't possible, scour your memory as much as possible. If you're not certain about something, it's probably better to put yes rather than lose coverage later.

If You're A Victim

If your claim is rejected, it can seem devastating, and it is. But there are steps you can take if you believe the company has acted in bad faith.

First, challenge the decision. Most companies have procedures in place to allow that. Gather your paperwork, do your research and make your case logically. In some instances, the decision will be reversed.

However, if a challenge doesn't work, you can always take your case to the Financial Ombudsman Service. Fill out their downloadable complaint form and return it, following instructions. They will look into the matter and reach a decision. Their criteria are different from the insurance companies. They'll establish whether the consumer lied deliberately on the application, or whether the omission was reasonable because or the way in which the questions were asked.

If all else fails, you can take the insurance company to court. Be warned, however, that it can be a lengthy, expensive procedure. One case that was resolved recently (in favour of the individual, not the company) dragged on for six years.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • Samh1979
    Re: Builder's Scams
    Don’t fall foul of Arren Safavi from Lancashire decking. He looks and acts all professional however once the deposit is paid that’s him doing a…
    22 April 2022
  • Dia
    Re: Sky TV Scam
    I just received a call from someone saying from Sky not sure if it was genuine. Asked me for my address. Then my bank details, then my password for my…
    2 April 2022
  • Pepper
    Re: Scams And Seniors
    Scammed out of £12500 by a builder who has been to court several times. I paid by my debit card, have I any chance of getting compensation. I am…
    9 September 2021
  • snobbs
    Re: Builder's Scams
    We have been scammed by James Hookey & Libby Hookey... advertised for a roofer on fb, Libby contacted me to say James can help... he came quoted,…
    6 July 2021
  • Villager
    Re: Sky TV Scam
    I received a call from ‘Sky’ this week saying I had overpaid and was due a refund. This seemed fairly plausible as the day before I had telephoned Sky…
    10 June 2021
  • Sam
    Re: Builder's Scams
    Don't use Martin Jacques from swift cavity clear or swift building services based in Manchester.He did a awful job of my garden and charged thousands.
    1 June 2021
  • John
    Re: Bank Identification or BIN numbers Scam
    Okay I just don’t want to euryeurueiieoeoe you talking about to sleep or sleep no sleep sleep no cap on sleep and…
    6 May 2021
  • Scallywaggle
    Re: Builder's Scams
    I have been scammed by a man called James hookey, and his wife Libby hookey, from face book, asking for recommendation, for patio, The wife sends a…
    5 April 2021
  • don’t know
    Re: Vishing Scam
    Had a text message this morning form a mobile number saying that I’ve missed a delivery and that I needed to pay 1.50 to R.M. Lucky enough my iPhone…
    17 March 2021
  • d.a.smith
    Re: Builder's Scams
    DNF Builder and Plastering, based in North East (Newcastle/Gateshead/South Shields/Sunderland), run by David (Mancunian) and Ian. ***Do not…
    28 February 2021